Cash for Careless officials
Almost a year has passed since the Obama Administration has come into power and what has Obama accomplished? Well, he won the Nobel peace prize … and passed a stimulus package that so far looks to have been what critics predicted: a pointless increase in the nation’s debt to be placed on the shoulders of our children.
Even “Cash for Clunkers,” one program which has been largely praised as a success, looks to be, upon further examination, not quite as profitable as the Administration boasts, and possibly even a negative stimulus. Based on analyses by automotive consumer researchers, tax dollars ended up paying an average of $24,000 for each of the 125,000 cars sold under “Cash for Clunkers” that would not have been sold without it. It appears that this stimulus was less for the growth of the economy and more for the growth of government.
“For that price, the federal government could have purchased the 125,000 cars outright at manufacturer suggested retail prices, such as a Ford Fusion, Focus or even a Mustang, and then handed each of the recipients an additional bonus check averaging the Cash-for-Clunkers subsidy of $4,000. Or they could have bought every one of those 125,000 people a Smart car and then given them a check for $6,000.”
- thenewamerican.com
The main point really comes down to this: a government cannot take money from its citizens, then turn around and give small portions back to them, and call that a recovery. The most efficient way to accomplish an economic stimulus would be to simply allow the people to keep their money in the first place.
Although the Obama Administration is touting the success of their stimulus because earnings are up, this is really just because companies have fired half their workforce, so they’re getting a better bottom line while still bringing in lower revenues. In the human sense, the economy picks up when employment improves, and that is still getting worse. What do the numbers matter if people are out of work?
It seems the Obama Adminisration needs to go back to kindergarten to learn the same lesson in economics that was taught to me during that intense first year of education. In my kindergarten class, we were all given a certain amount of money to use at our imaginary grocery store. We were told we could buy whatever we wanted with that money. But of course, in the end, we learned a very heartbreaking lesson: when you run out of money, you can’t buy anything else.
The reality of our current situation is that we as a people have simply run out of money, and unlike my kindergarten teacher, you can’t just print more of it. Actually you can print more, but as one clever observer noted, it is like taking a bucket of water out of the deep end of the pool and pouring it into the shallow end in hopes of raising the level. Rather we just need to do as the kindergartners — work hard and wait patiently for earnings to increase.






I wish the Government would have bought my clunker, bought me a $24,000 dollar car, then given me a $4,000 check! The thing about all this is that by trying to get out of the economic slump we are in, all the actions are just putting us further and further into debt. We are still paying for FDR’s “Stimulus Package” and our kids will pay for what we (or our government) do today. I agree. Let’s go back to the basics which is roll up our sleeves, work hard, and help the people believe in the economy again.
Right on Natali, great article. You write articles like you sell dish network!
One problem with the government trying to “fix” the economy with a stimulus is that it tries to preserve the structure of the economy as it is now. It tries to keep car companies and business and house prices up just like they were for the last decade. But the seeming prosperity of the last decade was the result of an artificial boom created by loose monetary policy. The market is trying to correct for all the bad investments that were made during that boom, and the government doing everything it can to stop it. The government is trying to sustain something that is inherently unsustainable. The structure of the economy is broken–it needs to change. The government doesn’t know how to do that, but the market does.
Leave a comment!
Arts & Entertainment »
The Old Spice Phenomenon
How often do we as consumers get so wrapped up in an advertisement that we continually wait in anticipation for the next commercial? This seems like a new concept, but with the popularity of Youtube, viral …
Issues & Ideas »
Facebook privacy again…
“…Don’t mess with the privacy stuff for a long time.”
This is the main lesson Mark Zuckerberg, CEO of Facebook, said he has learned, in an interview from the New York Times after announcing ’simpler’ privacy …
Life & Living »
Summer nights with no Ice Cream?
As I’ve said before, I am a Pacific Northwesterner, meaning I’m used to rain and overcast summers. This is my first summer in Utah and the heat is killing me. Thus, I’ve been looking for …
News & Politics »
Election advice from people with power
It’s that time of year—the time when BYUSA busybodies are starting to come out of the woodwork. As they begin the election process, recruiting diehards and freshmen to wear their bandannas and wave their fliers, …
Sports & Adventure »
Defining Sport
The 2010 Winter Olympics are well under way. Americans have already claimed a number of prestigious gold
medals, and athletes of many nationalities have displayed acts of heroism in competition.
Every Olympic cycle, a number of phenomena …
Recent Posts
Recent Comments
Categories
Blogroll