Is Twitter replacing Journalists?
Many people watched captivated on Thursday as what people thought was a 6-year-old boy trapped in a hot air balloon finally came down to the ground. People were and still are tweeting about it left and right. Most sites led people to believe the boy was trapped in the balloon, but if you watched the landing of the balloon, it didn’t look like authorities believed the boy was in fact in the balloon as they poked a hole in the balloon and started hitting it down.
Also yesterday (actually as this balloon boy incident was going on), my class was participating in a Cover-it-live event with journalists from around the nation about how journalists should, can, and do use Twitter in their reporting stages and in general. Some people said they get great sources from being on Twitter, others questioned how reliable a source is on Twitter and still more were totally against using Twitter.
Twitter for me is a way to see what people are talking about and if I am interested in the topic, I research it more to really know what is going on. Just like the balloon boy twittering that went on. Many people did not know what they were talking about and stated opinions as facts. If I had just gone from what people were saying on Twitter for a story, I would not get my information correct.
This is why I do not think Twitter or Blogs for that matter will replace professional reporting and journalists, like some people are saying. Yes, people can learn about a subject and write about it through their social media of choice, but do they go out there and interview important people involved in the story to see what is really going on? Many of those who do what people are calling “citizen journalism” get much of their information from news sources in the first place.
I know journalism is going through a tough time right now, but I still believe it will pull through and be able to adapt to the technology-minded world. Call me an optimist, but I think there will still be a need for people to go to J-School and learn the ins and outs of journalism and reporting in the future. Just like people are trained to be teacher or a scientist, journalists are trained in what they do and follow guidelines that others who are not trained to do so do not, making them more qualified and reliable than a man on the street.
Interestingly enough, one of my BYU professors said this year the amount of applications for the print journalism emphasis was actually up from previous years.







I have to agree. While “citizen journalism” seems attractive, it just doesn’t work the same way as professional journalism does. While you may have a few people who are actually on the scene, they are usually untrained and perhaps even biased. These bloggers and tweeters often write about what they think of an event or situation, rather than endeavoring to objectively analyze it and present it fairly. And all those who weren’t actually there just link to or retweet citations from others who wrote about it.
Professional journalists, on the other hand, delve into the details of the events and try to present both sides in an informative way. These people are in it because they make a living from it, and (we presume) will do their best to do a good job. That financial motivation is something blogger- or tweeter-in-the-street (usually) doesn’t have.
Citizen journalism is a useful thing, and it certainly has its place. But I don’t believe it ever will (or should) totally replace professional journalism.
[...] (or at least tries to). While it sounds like an appealing alternative to professional journalism, citizen journalism simply doesn’t work. Bloggers link to each other, tweeters retweet things they like. But amateurs simply don’t [...]
Leave a comment!
Arts & Entertainment »
The Old Spice Phenomenon
How often do we as consumers get so wrapped up in an advertisement that we continually wait in anticipation for the next commercial? This seems like a new concept, but with the popularity of Youtube, viral …
Issues & Ideas »
Facebook privacy again…
“…Don’t mess with the privacy stuff for a long time.”
This is the main lesson Mark Zuckerberg, CEO of Facebook, said he has learned, in an interview from the New York Times after announcing ’simpler’ privacy …
Life & Living »
Summer nights with no Ice Cream?
As I’ve said before, I am a Pacific Northwesterner, meaning I’m used to rain and overcast summers. This is my first summer in Utah and the heat is killing me. Thus, I’ve been looking for …
News & Politics »
Election advice from people with power
It’s that time of year—the time when BYUSA busybodies are starting to come out of the woodwork. As they begin the election process, recruiting diehards and freshmen to wear their bandannas and wave their fliers, …
Sports & Adventure »
Defining Sport
The 2010 Winter Olympics are well under way. Americans have already claimed a number of prestigious gold
medals, and athletes of many nationalities have displayed acts of heroism in competition.
Every Olympic cycle, a number of phenomena …
Recent Posts
Recent Comments
Categories
Blogroll